Have you ever thought about starting an indoor farm?
Why don't more people have indoor farms?
Well here's a dirty little secret:
Most people don't know how to start.
In order to get some answers, we recently caught up with Eric Amyot, CEO and co-founder of Modularfarms.co, a start-up company developing new cutting edge solutions for commercial vertical and urban farmers.
Topics we discussed included:
- Indoor Farming costs (unit economics)
- What you absolutely must do before selling any produce
- Lighting for profitable indoor urban farming
- The types of crops to consider when generating an ROI
- Picking your first crop to grow as an urban farming beginner
- Understanding the market for produce from micro-urban farms
- The Core components of "controlled atmosphere" in vertical farming
Ready to learn A TON?
A well designed indoor growing system has 3 core components.
A typical system that's well thought out and is designed for the most chance of success will have:
1) Expert Lighting:
"I can’t stress enough how much we’ve seen increases in crop productivity and the proper checks and balances in place for plant transpiration, canopy saturation of light, etc. So having really good lights in a system really makes a big difference, if you’re looking at having the most yield possible. So, good quality lights (is the first pillar)."
2) Controlled Atmosphere:
"A controlled environment is one that controls all ambient or external influences, so, literally cutting off the outside world, so everything from water, to airflow, and the actual air itself is recirculated within the system.
What that really permits for us is to have a constant, or consistent environment for the plants to grow up in. So an example would be today I’m just sitting on the east side of Toronto right now, in Ontario, it’s not too cold today but it has been very recently, about -20 degrees Celsius.
If we were using a containerized farming system or a shipping container farm, or even a modular farm that was using external air pulled into the system, it would be pulling that cold dry air, depending on the day, into the farm, which means the system always has to fluctuate, ebb and flow a lot.
That means increased cost for electricity as the system cycles through heat and cold, dehumidification, etc. but blocking the outside air means the farm is always a consistent 72 degrees or 74 degrees Fahrenheit in our instance. So controlled environment is very important, keeping out bugs, keeping the air temperature and the humidity exactly what they (the plants) need."
3) Growing Space:
"People will take this for granted a lot, especially in some of the tighter, condensed growing environments like shipping container farms, some of them are very well thought out, some of them try to pack too much stuff into very little space thinking that if you can just squeeze in an extra 500 plants it’ll make a difference.
The reality is, you get too tight in that space it restricts the airflow, it restricts proper dehumidification, it can cause mold and mildew issues.
You can’t really put in a high intensity lighting system if the plants are too close to the lights because it’ll burn the plants, there are a lot of advantages of having that extra bit of space.
Space is king for sure, in tight growing spaces, so, again, adequate space for the plants to grow, and for the environment to be treated properly, a controlled environment to begin with, and really good lights."
"There’s a clear distinction to be made between somebody who wants to get their feet wet, so to speak, in urban agriculture, and that’s how I got started, I started tinkering, before we got our first shipping container farm, I bought a seedlings tray and a cheap LED light from Home Depot, and gave it a try.
So there’s a distinction to be made between somebody who wants to experience urban agriculture or just growing indoors, which could be in the living room or in the basement, versus somebody who wants to grow commercially, so if you’re starting on a small scale and just want to try it out, the reality is that the best solution is going to be the solution that’s within your budget, otherwise you’re not going to get started at all, so starting with a nice inexpensive T5 fluorescent light or T8 fluorescent light, I mean even if it’s something sitting in your shop, garage, or basement that you haven’t used for a while, it will still be a source of light for plants.
It might not be the best source of light for plants but it’s a source of light for plants. Same thing with scale, you don’t need to grow four thousand or five thousand plants at once, if it’s a trial and you just want to feed your family a little bit and experience maybe with ebb and flow or drip irrigation, it’s all about budget, so when we talk about enclosed environment or controlled atmosphere agriculture, the reality is that provides the optimal environment for the plant, so it allows us to control the relative humidity, air flow etc, the matter of the fact is that plants will grow in almost any environment, most of them are hearty enough, like kale, for example, mint, those things will grow in the cracks of a sidewalk , given the right conditions.
You don’t really need to really have high intensity LED lighting with the right spectrum , you don’t need high pressure sodium lights to grow kale and mint, for the first time, the reality is that it can be a joy and provide lots of health and benefits to your family if you just start on a very small scale with a very small budget, my advice is to just, get started.
Some considerations will be the expected outcomes too, are really important to discuss. Some people say, man look at all these videos online with these big plant factories or the big rooftop farms, or modular farms for example, and they grow these huge heads of lettuce and this fantastic abundance of kale, and it looks great, but then everyone’s at home at my dining room table, or in the basement in the corner, and I’m getting different effects, we’re getting kale that’s a little spindly, heads of lettuce, don’t look like they do in the grocery store. So as long as you have the right expectations starting out, and you know if you’re using a fluorescent instead of an LED or HPS, high pressure sodium light, that you’re going to get some apples to oranges comparison of the experience, then you won’t be disappointed."
"Just to keep it as simple as possible when we’re referring to T5 and T8, we’re referring to the gauge and diameter of the fluorescent tube, primarily, without getting into all the tech specs about it, so a T8, would be what you would typically see in your office, or in your classroom, up above in the ceiling, that’s the standard diameter, typically a 4 foot length fluorescent light tube. T5 is essentially the same thing except smaller, typically the length is much smaller, or it can be smaller, as small as a foot or two feet, and the diameter is smaller, which of course effects the output potentially, etc, but we’re referring to fluorescent lights when we talk about T5 and T8, and then of course LED’s and high pressure sodiums.
The one recommendation that we always have when we’re talking about fluorescent vs LED, regardless of the quality of either of those lights, is to consider pets and children around those lighting solutions as well, so in classrooms for example, or at home if you have little ones running around, especially those that are just at the age where they like to grab things and test things out on their own, there are a lot of inherent benefits of LED lights in growing food of course, but there’s also a safety measure too, an LED light is much more difficult to break, depending on the design of it, but most of them are fairly durable, rugged, and can be knocked over, and picked back up and plugged back in, a T5 or T8 fluorescent light, most of them if not all of them have a mercury component in the lightand are considered hazardous materials if they break, so that’s certainly a consideration we make to all of our school clients, is to always consider an LED investment, because it can be a little bit more expensive, actually in most cases about twice as expensive as a fluorescent solution, but it’s worth it for safety reasons."
"I would suggest that somebody grow whatever they want to grow, there’s no point in growing mint if you can’t stand it, because you’re not going to eat it and you’re not going to enjoy it, so that might deter you from proceeding, if you’re talking about simplicity, there’s a wealth of resources on the internet, I can’t even begin to scratch the surface of how much help there is on YouTube, obviously via Urban Vine, a lot of the collaborators and colleagues we participate in the industry with, there’s a lot of information out there, not only to help people decide what to grow but how to grow that crop.
I would say the most important thing is to be realistic, and those two matters or two principals: (1) one is grow something that you think you’ll enjoy eating, even if you’re head of lettuce isn’t huge like it is at the grocery store, or from a commercial hydroponic or aquaponic farm, the reality is that you’ll actually enjoy eating that romaine lettuce, even if it’s a little scraggly looking and the head is only half formed, at least you’ll be able to enjoy the fruits of your labor. (2) And the other one is the footprint of the plant as well, and the growth cycle, so, as an example, as a vegan, I eat a lot of quinoa, but I wouldn’t grow quinoa in my basement in a hydroponic set up, because the lifecycle and the footprint of the plant just don’t make sense. Just like corn too, you might say, well “man I’d really love myself a good cob of corn”, but growing corn in a seedling tray in your basement is not going to be the best idea, so be realistic about the lifecycle and the harvest cycle of the plant, and the physical size of the plant when it grows up.
Another good example would iceberg lettuce as well, a lot of us as North Americans consume iceberg lettuce, it’s not a bad thing, at least we’re eating some veggies, but the reality is that growing iceberg lettuce hydroponically is not the most effective plant, especially for beginners, the plant has a longer life cycle than a loose leaf lettuce like oak leaf or salad bowl or butter crunch or something or something of that nature, but the physical size of the plant if it was to grow properly is much larger, takes longer to harvest, so I think those would be the two considerations.
I wouldn’t recommend cucumber, as a start, fruiting plants, actually that’s another good point, fruiting plants are going to be a little more difficult as well, so strawberries, cucumbers, tomatoes, anything that develops a flower before it turns into a fruit or vegetable, is going to be more challenging.
Some plant varieties are self-pollinating, so we don’t need to worry about pollination so much, just air movement in the house, the dog walking by and wagging its tail is enough to pollinate some species of flowering plants, but you’d have to pick the specific breed or cultivar of plant to make sure you’re getting something that is self-pollinating, and most self-pollinating plants, or flowering fruit plants, will also mean that they’re going to be vine or creeping plants, which are going to be cumbersome to handle in a small system at home too, again, perfect example, the cucumber did fairly well in our farmwall, the vertical towers that I have in my living room, but the vines were literally growing across the floor, and wrapping around the lights and things like that, and things were difficult, so there’s a variety of reasons to not try fruiting plants at first, it will be less rewarding, almost assured, than it would be to just grow a simple head of lettuce or herb, or brassica of some sort."
"Technologies are starting to provide answers to profitability questions for urban farming companies at this point, the cost of LED lights, the cost of technology in general, the accessibility, so the advent of IOT the internet of things, and the ability to connect remotely with our devices and therefore our farms, to be able to monitor and remotely control aspects of those farming operations, small and large, are really helping with accessibility, so again the cost and connectivity of those technologies is really helping out, but there’s room for everybody to be honest with you.
While a very large commercial operation, like a warehouse farm, let’s say, 20,000 square feet in size, will obviously feed a larger community, the reality is that you can now get an awful lot of food out of a small containerized farm, or even a garage or basement f arm if it’s done properly and operated safely, to feed portions of a community, so the return on investment is now really related to the farming practices and the motivation.
So we don’t discourage anyone to get started at a hobby level for sure, but if we’re talking about transitioning from hobby to commercial, generating revenue and an ROI, it seems that most systems, if properly thought out, and that would include a look at the market the system is being deployed in as well, should provide an ROI in 3-5 years, which is within the expected range for new business startups, for successful business startups, so people shouldn’t expect to have an ROI in year 1, if someone is promising you that then be cautious of course, we’re seeing 3-5 years on average for the systems that we generate, sometimes it can be less if the crop that you’re growing is serving a particular market and has a very high value."
"Medicinal herbs, and I’m not referring to cannabis, I’m referring to more traditional Chinese medicines that are being explored in urban farms as well, an example from my perspective would be a niche client looking for a niche product all for themselves, so it could be as simple as kale, kale can generate a really good return in the right system, if you have a client that is willing to pay for it, a good example would be a client, a smoothie shop, and this is a real experience that I had about a year ago, I approached one of Canada’s larger smoothie franchises and introduced our product and our prices, they absolutely loved the product, but made it very clear that their core message was not, non GMO, local, organic, it was just cheap smoothies for the masses, so they had no interest, but their competitor, one of their competitors, was willing to pay the high value that they were seeking, because their core brand was, local, non-GMO, organic, sustainable, and they got it, it was marketing partnership for them, in essence, where the story was easy to tell and their customers were seeking those solutions at that brand and that banner.
So if you’re addressing the market properly and you’re starting on a small scale, as small as 200 or 400 square feet in a containerized f arming system or even in your, I don’t want to say home because I don’t people to think that they can just grow a commercial outfit out of their home, you can but it requires a lot of consideration for zoning and health and safety etc, but the opportunity to receive an ROI within 3 years is certainly realistic."
"We always insist that the customer take a look at their market first. It’s one thing to say that the technology looks available and the ROI seems ok on the surface or on paper, the reality is that if you’re in a market that has no demand for what you’ll supply, you can have the best technology and products in the world and it just won’t fetch that value you need to have to have that ROI, so going into your market is obviously imperative, in determining what your value is.
One thing I would caution people upon is a lot of people like to do arm-chair research, I do most of my research sitting at my desk, seeing what’s in the market, seeing what’s happening, but until you actually get out there and learn the market a little bit, and that doesn’t mean months and months of research it just means going to the farmer’s market, going to the grocery store, and picking up that bunch of parsley or that head of lettuce and seeing what the cost is, or not the cost, but the retail value of that food, talking to the grocery manager if possible and asking them what type of volume they require, if they have any pains or issues with the food that they grow.
It’s those types of conversations out in the field and on the ground that really make a big difference, because we can’t just assume. We have a lot of arm chair researchers, this isn’t to pigeonhole somebody as a type of person, again, we do it as well, but it can’t just be just research from our chair, a lot of people will a lot of fantastic research for months and months before they pick up the phone to call us to place an order or get to the point of placing an order, and they’ll refer to USDA websites and in Canada there are several provincial and federal websites that will offer recommended food values, so the commodity value of corn, or lettuce, or kale, or whatever the case, but those are typically based on import/export prices, and not locally grown, organic, non-GMO, sustainable food, so a lot of people will call and say, “Look I’ve been thinking about buying a modular farm”, as an example, “but based on the price of the modular farm and the operating cost of the modular farm, I can only get 25 cents for my head of lettuce, I’m never gonna make any money.
The reality is that is a set price based on the ebbs and flows of the international market and the national market, but not always reflective of your local market, so make sure you get out there and talk to the people who you would intend to buy your food. I also want to make sure that people are considering CSA models as well, so community supported agriculture, or direct to consumer, farm to plate, however you’d like to refer to it, is probably one of the most powerful models for people selling their food, no matter, whichever scale, so whether you have a 100 square foot system in your basement or garage, or a thousand square foot farm in a warehouse or a couple modular farms, sellingdirect to consumer whenever possible is going to net the highest yields and revenues for you and exclude the middle man. It will also be more rewarding in that you will see the immediate effects on your community.
Instead of just shipping your food off to warehouse to be sorted and sent to a grocery store, you’ll actually be able to interact with your customer and be that “local food hero”. So there are a lot of opportunities for good ROIs in almost any market, as long as you’re doing you’re market research first, and don’t discount thinking outside the box, a lot of crops, that are typical crops like lettuce and herbs, may not have room in your market because you live a couple miles away from a large (urban) farm which produces these things most of the year anyway. But there are lot of other things that are really hot on the market right now, such as edible flowers, edible orchids is an example of a huge value that actually rivals cannabis believe it or not, and it’s a crop that can be grown, it takes a little more dedication and education than just growing a head of lettuce, nonetheless, it’s an example of things (that maygenerate ROI). Imported crops are also really big too because we can control the atmosphere and the environment in most indoor applications, if it’s done properly, and it can be done on a budget by the way, so, let me touch on that for just a second, we talked about controlled atmosphere and environments and a modular farm and big commercial application, the reality is that if you have access to a small dehumidifier, a small air conditioner, even if it’s portable units, and you want to get started in your garage.
As long as you don’t have that door open all the time and the hot or the cold air coming in, and you keep the space closed, you can still wrap a simple timber frame and poly or plastic film, a wrap, around a growing space and use small tools to try and experiment with controlled environments, there are a lot of inexpensive DIY hacks out there that allow people to just try to control their environments a little bit, you don’t need a 200,000 dollar or half a million dollar investment to play with controlled environment.
So, controlled environment allows us to work with import product as well, like iceplant is a good example, a lot of people don’t really know what iceplant is, it resembles a jade plant, a little bit, a succulent, and it’s really hot on the Asian market right now, but as we know, North America is not just comprised of people from North America, there are a lot of people Asian palettes as well, including North Americans, so, iceplant has a good market in a lot of places in North America, but most people don’t even know that it exists. So those types of plants, those type of crops, thinking outside the box, going to your grocery store, going to your neighbors, whoever you’re going to be selling your food to, who you’d like to sell your food to, just chat with them, ask them what they wish they could have, and see if you can grow it."
If you liked this article, check out some of our other popular articles below!
[UPDATED FOR 2020] Interested to learn more about urban farming? Click now to get the exclusive top 11 books on Urban Farming!View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] In this article, you will learn all about the 3 key types of growing media (hydroponic, aeroponic, and aquaponic). Click to learn more!View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] In this article, we cover some of the CRAZY benefits of urban farming. You may find some of these benefits surprising. Click to learn more!View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] In this article you will learn 11 secrets that will allow you to easily improve your results when growing basil. Click to learn more!View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] In this article, you will learn 11 simple guidelines to think about before buying grow lights for indoor growing. Click to learn more!View Post
(UPDATED FOR 2020) What is vertical farming, and how does it work? This step-by-step 25 part guide breaks down everything that you need to know. Click now!View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] What is Precision Agriculture? What are the advantages, who are the most important precision agriculture companies? Click here to learn all of this and more...View Post
[UPDATED for 2020] What is Ag-Tech? What technologies count as Ag-Tech? What are the benefits and goals of Ag-Tech? What does the future of Ag-Tech look like? Click to learn more!View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] How do you control root aphids? In this post we will discuss the best solutions to control root aphids in your garden, indoor farm, and more! Click to learn...View Post
[UPDATED FOR 2020] What is Container Farming? How Does It Work? In this article you will learn all about Container Farming and how it is related to vertical farming. Click to learn more!View Post